SeatPlan Logo
Wanted the Musical on Broadway hero image

Wanted the Musical on Broadway Tickets

James Earl Jones Theatre, New York

Opens 15th October

The Wild West rides into Broadway as this new musical shares the mostly-true story of outlaw sisters Mary and Martha Clarke.

Wanted the Musical in New York

Broadway just got a little more lawless with the arrival of Wanted the Musical this Autumn! Set to an explosive score, experience the defiant story of two extraordinary women’s journey from farmgirls to legendary outlaws. Head to the James Earl Jones Theatre, in the heart of Times Square, for a “thrilling original musical” (The New York Times Critic’s Pick).

What is Wanted the Musical about?

Wanted the Musical is a new show based on the real story of Mary and Martha Clarke. Set in 1983 Texas, the two African-American twin sisters are determined to save their family and take fate into their own hands. In a bid to settle their mother’s debt and stop her losing her home, the sisters hide who they are and take what they are owed by passing themselves as white.

The History of Wanted the Musical

Originally titled Gun & Powder, the musical was created as part of the NYU Graduate Musical Theatre Writing Program in 2015. The entire show was rewritten and further developed over the years until its sold-out world premiere at the Signature Theatre in Virginia in 2020. A subsequent run at the Paper Mill Playhouse took place four years later in 2024. There, it obtained a New York Times Critic’s Pick.

Wanted the Musical set its goal on premiering on Broadway in early 2025, with a pre-Broadway workshop scheduled in the summer. Now, it heads to the James Earl Jones Theatre, with previews beginning in October 2026.

Wanted the Musical on Broadway Cast

  • Mary – Solea Pfeiffer
  • Martha – Liisi LaFontaine

Solea Pfeiffer will star in the Broadway debut of Wanted Musical. Her theatre credits include the first national tour of Hamilton and West Side Story at the Hollywood Bowl. She also starred in Evita, Hadestown and Moulin Rouge! The Musical. Sofia recently starred in Tyler Perry’s movie A Jazzman’s Blues.

Liisi LaFontaine will star alongside Solea as Martha Clarke. Her stage debut was in the West End production of Dreamgirls in 2016. Her other stage credits include Moulin Rouge! The Musical and Drag: The Musical.

The complete cast for the musical is to be announced.

Wanted Musical Creative Team

Wanted the MusicalOn Broadway features book and lyrics by Angelica Chéri, a real-life descendant of the Sisters Clarke.

Obie Award winner and Tony nominee Stevie Walker-Webb will direct the production. His credits, both on and Off Broadway, include Ain’t No Mo’, One in Two, and Black Odyssey.

The creative team also features Austin Cook as music director, Chelsey Arce as choreographer and music by Ross Baum.

Book Tickets for Wanted the Musical in New York

Be front and centre for a bold new addition to Broadway this autumn. Be transported to Texas, 1893 where two infamous outlaws take fate into their own hands in a high-octane new musical not to be missed. Don't miss out - secure your tickets for Wanted the Musical on Broadway at the James Earl Jones Theatre today! 

Performance dates:
15 Oct 2026 - 15 Apr 2027
Running time:
2 hours and 15 minutes including an intermission.
Venue:
James Earl Jones Theatre
138 W 48th St, New York, NY 10036
Get directions
Age recommendation:
Best for age 14+
Audience Notes:

Wanted the Musical On Broadway opens on October 15. The above closing date is provisional and subject to change, with full dates for the run to be confirmed.

Categories:

More Shows You Might Like

Six the Musical on Broadway
& Juliet on Broadway
Hamilton on Broadway
Your basket is empty.