SeatPlan Logo
The Play That Goes Wrong hero image

The Play That Goes Wrong Tickets

New World Stages - Stage 4, New York
Save up to $25.00
Cheap tickets on 4 performances from 20th May. Find offers
Save up to $25.00
106 ticket offers on 4 performances from 20th May. From $98.00 Find offers

Mischief Theatre’s hilarious comedy of errors will leave you in stitches, as a community theater group's latest murder mystery goes awry.

The Play That Goes Wrong in New York City

If you love the mystery of an Agatha Christie novel combined with laugh-out-loud comedy – Mischief Theatre’s chaotically brilliant The Play That Goes Wrong is just the ticket! The West End’s longest-running comedy is back in town but this time at Off-Broadway's New World Stages, located in the heart of Manhattan. Experience firsthand what happens when a fictional community theater group desperately try in vain to stage a murder mystery without anything going wrong. Secure your tickets to see The Play That Goes Wrong today!

What Is The Play That Goes Wrong About?

Meet The Cornley Polytechnic Drama Society, a collective of accident-prone actors who are staging their latest production, The Murder at Haversham Manor. Unfortunately for them, nothing goes smoothly! In just over two hours, watch as the cast scramble with collapsing scenery, missed cues and more as they try to reach the curtain call in one piece.

An award-winning hit that is a riot from start to finish, The Play That Goes Wrong packs plenty of surprises in there, as well as some brilliantly crafted audience interaction thrown in there for good measure too!

Play That Goes Wrong Cast and Creatives

Main cast:

  • Robert — Brent Bateman
  • Chris — Chris Lanceley
  • Jonathan — Chris French
  • Sandra — Liana Hunt
  • Trevor — Kolby Kindle
  • Annie — Joanie Anderson
  • Dennis — Trevor Braun
  • Max — Samuel Douglas

The understudies are Laura D’Andre, Brandon Haagenson, Jemma Jane, and Jake Bentley Young.

The History of The Play That Goes Wrong

Mischief Theatre burst onto the West End scene with The Play That Goes Wrong in 2012, and it has been running at the Duchess Theatre since 2014. An instant hit with theatregoers and critics, the play has embarked on UK tours and won several awards, including the Olivier Award for Best New Comedy in 2015. 

Its transfer to Broadway took place in 2017, with the original cast starring in its first home at the Lyceum Theatre, where it played for over 500 performances. Now at New World Stages, where its played since 2019, this is a remarkable journey for a production that originated from the upstairs of a pub theatre in London.

The Play That Goes Wrong Reviews

This laugh-out-loud comedy is a hit in New York City, whilst it has been playing in the West End for over 10 years! Critics love it here, describing it as “well-disciplined in the art of being hilariously bad” (amNY), and a “broad, silly and deliciously demented show” (Variety).

Tickets for The Play That Goes Wrong Off-Broadway

Agatha Christie meets local community theater in the most hilarious way! Book tickets to check out “the funniest play Broadway has ever seen!” (The Huffington Post) at New World Stages. If you love big laughs, chaos and pitch-perfect escapist comedy – The Play That Goes Wrong is just that and more!

Performance dates:
20 May 2026 - 06 Sep 2026
Running time:
2 hours including an intermission.
Venue:
New World Stages - Stage 4
340 West 50th Street, New York, NY 10019
Get directions
Age recommendation:
Ages 8+.
Categories:

Show Times

MatineeEvening
Monday-7.00pm
Tuesday--
Wednesday-7.00pm
Thursday2.00pm7.00pm
Friday-7.00pm
Saturday2.00pm8.00pm
Sunday2.00pm
3.00pm
7.00pm
How Long is The Play That Goes Wrong?
The Play That Goes Wrong running time is 2 hours including an intermission.
Matinee Shows
Performances start at 2.00pm and finish at 4.00pm or start at 3.00pm and finish at 5.00pm.
Evening Shows
Performances start at 7.00pm and finish at 9.00pm or start at 8.00pm and finish at 10.00pm.

Frequently Asked Questions

How much are The Play That Goes Wrong tickets?

The Play That Goes Wrong tickets are priced from $98 to $191.

Where is The Play That Goes Wrong playing in New York?

The Play That Goes Wrong is playing at the New World Stages - Stage 4, 340 West 50th Street, New York, NY 10019.

What is the age recommendation for The Play That Goes Wrong?

The Play That Goes Wrong is ages 8+.

How long is The Play That Goes Wrong?

The running time for The Play That Goes Wrong at New World Stages - Stage 4 is 2 hours.

Is there an intermission during The Play That Goes Wrong?

Yes, there is a 15 minute intermission about halfway through The Play That Goes Wrong.

Can I buy tickets for The Play That Goes Wrong at the box office?

Yes you can buy from the New World Stages - Stage 4 box office where you will pay the face value ticket price, sometimes with a small booking fee. Search on SeatPlan to get the best prices and deals in one search including discounts not available at the box office.

What is the refund / cancellation policy?

Tickets for The Play That Goes Wrong are generally non-refundable and non-exchangeable.

SeatPlan works with multiple suppliers to find the best deal for you. Each supplier has their own refund and cancellation policy, which you can review on the payment page before you complete your purchase.

More Shows You Might Like

Your basket is empty.